Training Course of Small Scale Water Resources Project (SSWRP-II) Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) and Mitigation Measures Dr. A.K.M. Saiful IslamBangladesh University of Engineering and Technology
Lecture Topic TEU, BMF , IW Environmental Parameters aiful Islam . S Potential Impact on infrastructure development .M.K projects r. A D Thana Road Project Thana Irrigation Schemes easures @ Thana Drainage and Embankment Projects Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) itigation M Environmental Protection Measures and M IAE
T Environmental Parameters EU, BMF is components of environment. It can be grouped into major components. , IW aiful Islam . S .M ECOLOGY .K r. A D easures @ PHYSICO- CHEMICAL itigation M HUMAN INTEREST and M IAE
T Ecology EU, BMF , IW Aquatic Terrestrial aiful Islam . S Fisheries .M Forest .K r. A Eutrophication Wildlife D Aquatic Weeds Species diversity easures @ Species diversity Endangered species Endangered species itigation M and M IAE
T Physico-chemical EU, BMF , IW Land Groundwater aiful Islam Erosion and Siltation . S Regional Hydrology .M .K Backwater Effect Recharge r. A Bank stability D Water table Drainage Water Pol ution Soil characteristics easures @ Surface water Atmosphere Regional Hydrology itigation M Air pol ution Silt Load and M Dust Pol ution IA Water Pol ution E Noise Pol ution
T Human Interest EU, BMF , IW Health Socio-Economic aiful Islam Land Loss . S Diseases .M Crop Production .K r. A Sanitation Aquaculture D Nutrients Irrigation Navigation easures @ Aesthetic Flood Control Landscape Transport itigation M Re-settlement Recreation Employment and M IA Agro-industrial E
T Potential Impacts on Environment EU, BMF , IW A change in system exerts certain influence on aiful Islam many different environmental parameters . S resulting a net positive or negative impact on the .M.K environment. r. A D Impact on major Infrastructure development easures @ projects such as: Thana road projects Thana irrigation schemes itigation M Thana Drainage and embankment projects and M IAE
T Ecological Impact EU, BMF , IW (a) Fisheries: Fisheries aiful Islam (-) Roads prevent longitudinal and . S lateral migration of fishes in the flood .M.K plain r. A (-) Obstruct movement of fishes onto D natural feeding and breeding grounds in the flood plain. Fish breeding ground (b) Forest: easures @ (-) Roads running through forest area and plantations may be the cause of itigation M destruction of trees in the forest and alteration of ecology of the forest. and M IAE Road running through forest
T Ecological Impact EU, BMF , IW (c) Plantation: (+) The roadsides may be used for plantation of trees which is Roadside plantation aiful Islam favorable impact of road . S construction. .M (d) Wetland and Wetland Habitant: .K (-) The road may encroach r. A D wetlands which may alter the ecology of wetlands and may cause destruction of wetland habitat. wetland easures @ (e) Nuisance Plant/Eutrophication: (-) The Roads running through forest area and plantations may be itigation M the cause of destruction of trees in the forest and alteration of ecology and M of the forest. IAE Eutrophication
T Physico-chemical Impact EU, BMF , IW (a) Erosion and Siltation (-) causes erosion during flood and siltation in the aiful Islam . S downstream. .M.K (b) Drainage Congestion /Water r. A logging Road erosion D (-) roads interfere with cross drainage and can cause flooding or drainage easures @ congestion in adjacent areas during periods of high itigation M precipitation. (-) May cause crop damage, and M water pol ution and breeding IAE of mosquitoes. Road side water logging
T Physico-chemical Impact EU, BMF , IW (c) Regional Hydrology/Flooding aiful Islam (-) Roads constructed across flood . S plains perpendicular to the direction of .M water flow cause back water effect .K and increase duration, frequency and r. A extent of flooding in the up stream. D (d) Obstruction to Waste water flow Road obstruction to drainage easures @ (-) Roads may obstruct the drainage of sewage and industrial waste water loading to serious pol ution problem. itigation M (e) Dust /Noise Pol ution (-) Dust raised from unpaved rural and M roads and blown by the vehicles can IAE pose a health hazard and damage vegetation along the sides of the road. Dust pollution
T Impact on Human Interest EU, BMF , IW (a) Loss of Agricultural Lands aiful Islam (-) Construction of any road is associated . S with the loss of agricultural lands. .M.K (b) Generation of Employment r. A Opportunities D (+) Construction of road generates temporary employment during project Agricultural land implementation and permanent easures @ employment during maintenance phase. (c) Navigation and Boat Communication itigation M (-) Roads interference with navigation and boat communication at least for certain and M period of the year. IA Road construction E
T Impact on Human Interest EU, BMF , IW (d) Commercial and Service Facilities aiful Islam (+) The thana roads provide benefit of fast communication . S communication, transport facilities etc. .M.K (e) Industrial Activities r. A D (+) Road communication promotes industrial activities. (f) Irrigation Facilities easures @ Borrow-pit Irrigation (+) Borrow-pits by the side of the roads provide facility for smal scale irrigation. itigation M (g) Landscape (-) Scattered borrow pits, unauthorized and M growth around road , erosion result in IAE marred landscape. Scattered borrow-pit
Training Course of T Small Scale Water Resources Project (SSWRP-II) EU, BMF , IW Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) aiful Islam . S .M.K r. A D easures @ itigation M and M IAE
TE Environmental Impact Assessment U, BMF (EIA) , IW Assessment of the beneficial and adverse aiful Islam changes in environment resources or values . S resulting from a proposed project. .M.K r. A D Essential Elements 1. Identification of possible positive or negative easures @ impacts of the project. 2. Quantifying impacts with respect to common base.3. Preparation of mitigation plan to offset the negative itigation M impacts. and M IAE
TEU, B Methods of Assessment MF , IW Environmental Impact Value aiful Islam . S .M.K n r. A EIV = ∑ V ( W ) D i i i=1 easures @ Vi = Relative change of the environmental quality of parameters itigation M Wi= Relative importance or weight or parameter and M IA N = total number of environmental parameters E
TE Quantification of Environmental U, BMF Impact , IW Changes of environmental aiful Islam parameters . S .M.K Severe (+5 or -5) Severe r. A D Higher (+4 or -4) Higher Moderate (+3 or -3) Moderate Low easures @ Low (+2 or -2) Very Low (+1 or -1) Very low itigation M No change No change (0) 0 1 2 3 4 5 and M IAE
TE Relative importance of U, BMF Environmental Parameters , IW Al parameters are not equal importance or aiful Islam weight. . S .M.K It varies from country to country r. A D In Bangladesh flood, employment, agriculture, fisheries carry more importance. easures @ In next slide, a summary of relative importance of parameters for Thana Road project is presented. itigation M and M IAE
T EIA Procedure EU, BMF , IW 1. Preparatory Works – study report aiful Islam . S 2. Data collection – from al sources, survey .M.K 3. Data Analysis – convert to change scale r. A D 4. Impact Evaluation – relative weight easures @ 5. Mitigation and Monitoring Plan 6. Preparation of Report – help decision itigation M makers and M IAE
ENVIRONMENTAL PARAMETERS Relative Degree of EIV TE Importance Impact U, B Value MF I. ECOLOGICAL -19 , IW Fisheries 10 -2 Forest 5 0 aiful Islam Tree Plantation 2 +1 . S .M Wetland/Wetland Habitant 4 0 .K r. A Nuisance Plant/Eutrophication 1 -1 D II. PHYSICO-CHEMICAL -13 Erosion and Siltation 2 -1 easures @ Regional Hydrology/Flooding 6 -1 Drainage Congestion/Water logging 5 -1 itigation M Obstruction to Waste Water Flow 3 0 and M Dust Pol ution/Noise Pol ution 2 0 IAE
ENVIRONMENTAL PARAMETERS Relative Degree of EIV TEU Importanc Impact , B e Value MF III. HUMAN INTEREST +27 , IW Loss of Agricultural Lands 8 +3 Employment Opportunities 8 +4 aiful Islam Navigation/Boat Communication 3 -3 . S .M Commercial and Service Facilities 6 +3 .K r. A Industrial Activities 3 +2 D Irrigation Facilities 2 +3 Landscape 2 -1 easures @ Total Environmental Impact Value -5 itigation M and M IAE
Training Course of T Small Scale Water Resources Project (SSWRP-II) EU, BMF , IW aiful Islam . S .M.K Adverse Environmental Impacts and r. A D Mitigation Measures easures @ itigation M and M IAE
TEU, B 1. Loss fish breeding MF , IW 1. Action: aiful Islam Loss of breading, nursery and . S feeding ground in flood plain. .M.K 1. Impact: Fish breeding r. A D Reduction in Fish protein consumption. Unemployment of fisherman. easures @ 1. Mitigation Measures: Allow controlled flooding. itigation M Compensate the loss by fish and M culture. IAE Fish farm
TEU, B 2. Obstruction to fish migration MF , IW 2. Action: aiful Islam . S Obstruction to mitigation of fish. .M.K 2. Impact: r. A D Same as 1. 2. Mitigation Measures: Fish ladder easures @ Provide adequate opening in roads and embankments along itigation M routes of fish migration. and M IAE Fish pass
TEU, B 3. Uncontrol ed Pesticide MF , IW 3. Action: aiful Islam Reproduction failure and . S destruction of fish by .M.K uncontrol ed use of pesticide. r. A D 3. Impact: Applying Pesticide Same as 1. 3. Mitigation Measures: easures @ Adopt Integrated Pest Management (IPM) for pest itigation M control. Prevent drainage from and M IA agriculture land from E reaching water bodies. Bugs used in IPM
TEU, BMF , IW aiful Islam . S .M.K r. A D easures @ itigation M and M IAE
TEU, B 4.Drying up of wetland MF , IW 4. Action: Drying up of the wetlands for aiful Islam agriculture purpose and . S destruction of habitat for fish, .M.K birds, amphibians etc. r. A 4. Impact: D Reduction in Fishery. Elimination of species of fish, birds, amphibians etc. easures @ Disruption of wetland ecology. 4. Mitigation Measures: Avoid complete drying up of itigation M wetlands and swamp land. Restore alternative habitat for endangered species. and M IAE wetland
TEU, B 5.Cutting trees MF , IW 5. Action: aiful Islam Clearing of forest lands and cutting of trees . S within the right-of-way of the road. .M.K 5. Impact: r. A Cutting forest D Reduction in forest cover. Reduction in forest products. Disruption of forest ecology. easures @ 5. Mitigation Measures: Find alternative route to avoid forest itigation M through planning exercise. Replace the trees by plantation along and M road sides. IA Cutting trees on road E
TEU, B 6.Spreading Nuisance plants MF , IW 6. Action: aiful Islam Spreading of nuisance plants from . S borrow pit. .M.K 6. Impact: r. A D Damage crops during flood. 6. Mitigation Measures: Incorporate destruction of such easures @ plants in maintenance program. Convert the plants into a compost itigation M for application as a soil conditioner/manure. Nuisance plants and M IAE
TEU, B 7.Pol ution from drainage MF , IW 7. Action: aiful Islam Discharge nutrient enriched . S agricultural land drainage in .M surface water. .K 7. Impact: r. A D Causes eutrophication and surface water pol ution. Makes the water unsuitable for easures @ beneficial uses. Destroys aquatic environment. 7. Mitigation Measures: itigation M Prevent agricultural land Agriculture drainage pollution drainage from reaching from and M IA reaching surface waters. E
TEU, B 8.Water pol ution MF , IW 8. Action: Reaching residues of pesticides aiful Islam . S in surface and groundwater from .M agricultural lands. .K 8. Impact: r. A D Cause water pollution. Contaminates sources of water supply. easures @ Pesticides residues accumulate in bio-mass. 8. Mitigation Measures: itigation M Reduce use of pesticides through IPM. and M Prevent agricultural land Agriculture runoff IAE drainage from reaching surface water.
TEU, B 9.Erosion and Siltation MF , IW 9. Action: Erosion of road and embankment surfaces aiful Islam and sides, road openings, bed and banks of . S rivers/canals subsequent silation in down .M stream. .K 9. Impact: r. A Cause damage to road and embankment. D Affect stability of road/embankment and their structures. Increases turbidity of water. Erosion of embankment easures @ Siltation of canal bed and agricultural lands. 9. Mitigation Measures: Select appropriate soils for road and embankment construction. itigation M Compact the road materials properly. Provide proper slope for surface drainage and M and vegetation cover. IAE Provide adequate opening for discharge of flood and accumulated rain water. Sediment Loading
TE 10.Drainage congestions and U, BMF water logging , IW 10. Action: aiful Islam Drainage congestion and . S water logging .M.K 10. Impact: r. A Crop damage and loss of D Drainage canal agricultural lands. Cause water pol ution. easures @ Provide ground fro mosquito breeding. 10. Mitigation Measures: itigation M Provide adequate opening for drainage. and M IA Provide facilities for E pumping of congested Pumping of drained water water.
TE 11. Disruption of Regional U, BMF Hydrology , IW 11. Action: Disruption of regional hydrology aiful Islam through obstruction of flood flow. . S .M Back water effect due to .K constructions across flood plains. r. A 11. Impact: D Increase duration, severity and frequency of flood. Hydrologic Cycle Changes flooding pattern and easures @ ground water recharge. 11. Mitigation Measures: Avoid road construction across the flood plain in the direction itigation M perpendicular to flood flow. Provide adequate opening for and M flood flow. IAE Road across flow direction
T 12. Backflow from drainage canal EU, BMF , IW 12. Action: aiful Islam Backflow of water through . S .M drainage canals. .K 12. Impact: r. A D Causes early flooding. 12. Mitigation Measures: Gate of regulator easures @ Install regulator to control inflow and itigation M outflow through drainage canal. and M IAE Regulator
T 13. Obstruction to waste water EU, BMF , IW 13. Action: Obstruction to waste water flow aiful Islam by roads and embankments. . S .M 13. Impact: .K r. A Create water pol ution. D Deteriorates quality of environment. Adequate drainage easures @ 13. Mitigation Measures: Provide drainage structure. itigation M Install pumping facilities. and M Install treatment plant for IAE waste water treatment. Drainage structure
T 14. Dust blowing from construction EU, BMF , IW 14. Action: Dust blowing from unpaved roads during construction and movement aiful Islam of vehicles. . S 14. Impact: .M.K Health hazards due to dust r. A pol ution. D Dust blowing Damage to vegetation and trees along the road. 14. Mitigation Measures: easures @ Control moisture content during construction by watering. itigation M Stabilize road surface with a suitable stabilizer. Compaction and M Increase vegetation cover on IA road surface and slopes. E Vegetationcover
15. Pol uted irrigation water TEU, BMF 15. Action: , IW Use of irrigation water with high and imbalance salt content. 15. Impact: aiful Islam Increase soil salinity and . S alkanity/acidity .M.K Alteration of soil texture and permeability. r. A Irrigation tail water may contain D Affects soil fertility. pollutants such as pesticide 15. Mitigation Measures: residues, sediment, nutrients Use surface water where available. and salt. easures @ Conduct chemical analysis of ground water before use and select the aquifer producing good quality water. itigation M Determine salinity of surface water in coastal areas before use as and M irrigation water. IAE Purification of polluted irrigation water by using riparian plants.
T 16. Contaminated irrigation water EU, BMF , IW 16. Action: Use of irrigation water with high iron aiful Islam content. . S .M 16. Impact: .K Impart reddish color to top soil. r. A D Changes soil texture and permeability. 16. Mitigation Measures: Contaminated water Look for an alternative water source, easures @ the right strata producing water with low iron content. itigation M Detain the aerated water in a reservoir, canal before application in and M the field. IAE Clear water for irrigation
T 17. Loss of agricultural land EU, BMF , IW 17. Action: Loss of agricultural land. aiful Islam 17. Impact: . S .M Deprives a group of farmers of their .K means of living. r. A D Increases landlessness in the area. Agricultural land Reduces employment in agriculture. Affects agricultural production. easures @ 17. Mitigation Measures: Plan the project to avoid fertile agricultural land. itigation M Rehabilitate the affected people. Generate employment opportunities in and M IA other activities. E Loss of land due to road
TEU, B 18. Obstruction to navigation MF , IW 18. Action: aiful Islam Obstruction to navigation and . S plying of boat. .M.K 18. Impact: r. A D Disruption of cheap mode of transportation. Opening for navigationShould be above HFL Adverse effects on communication. easures @ 18. Mitigation Measures: Provide openings at major itigation M routes and construct road structures leaving adequate and M clearance above high flood level IA for plying of boats. E Box culvert bridge
T 19. Change of Land ownership pattern EU, BMF , IW 19. Action: Change in land ownership aiful Islam . S pattern within project area. .M.K r. A 19. Impact: D Inadequately distribution of Unequal distribution of water project benefits. easures @ 19. Mitigation Measures: itigation M Regulation of land ownership transfer in the and M IA project area. E Irrigation canal
T 20. Inadequate landscape EU, BMF , IW 20. Action: aiful Islam Inadequate considerations to land . S use and landscape. .M.K 20. Impact: r. A Landscape disfiguration by irregular Borrow pits D borrowpits, deep cuts, fil s, unplanned growth of shops, and other services. easures @ 20. Mitigation Measures: Replant disfigured surfaces. Use a design to blend with itigation M landscape. Prevent unplanned construction and M IA and unauthorized uses of roads E and embankments. Blend landscape due to construction
TEU, B References: MF , IW aiful Islam . S Guidelines on environmental issues .M.K related to physical planning, LGED, r. A D 1992. easures @ Environmental Impact Assessment, CERM, BUET, 2003. itigation M and M IAE
TE Thank you ! U, BMF , IW aiful Islam . S .M.K r. A D easures @ itigation M and M IAE